Bascom Hill studying in the library the capitol building in springtime students work together

News Item

Wisconsin Innocence Project Challenge to Bite-Mark Evidence Aided by DNA Test

Posted: 2008.07.10

The Wisconsin Innocence Project, led by Attorney Byron Lichstein, has brought new DNA evidence to challenge a 1984 murder conviction based on the controversial forensic technique of bite-mark analysis.

Lichstein has asked prosecutors to vacate the conviction of Robert Lee Stinson, whose DNA has been found not to be that in saliva found on the victim. A review of testimony from a dental scientist and law professor that convicted Stinson is under way, and the entire field of bite-mark comparison is being called into question. The only evidence against Stinson in his 1985 was the bite-mark analysis.

Forensic experts reviewing the case have found that "there is little or no correlation of Robert Lee Stinson’s dentition to the bite marks."

A detailed article on the case appears in the Chicago Tribune of Thursday, July 10, 2008, which can be read online at http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/chi-bite-mark-exonerationjul10,0,2835607.story .

Want to Help?

As we move forward, you can help. Though we do not charge for our services, we welcome contributions to the Center. Please join the mission by contributing!

Find out how to make a donation now!